Whey vs Plant Protein: Which Should You Choose?

The whey vs. plant protein debate has gotten louder as plant-based eating goes mainstream. Whey loyalists point to superior amino acid profiles. Plant protein advocates highlight sustainability and digestibility. So who’s right?

Both have legitimate strengths. The best choice depends on your body, your diet, and your goals — not on marketing. Let’s look at the evidence.

For this comparison, we’re using Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey and Orgain Organic Plant Protein as representative examples of each category.

Amino Acid Profile

#

This is where whey has a genuine advantage. Whey protein contains all essential amino acids in high concentrations, with particular strength in leucine — the amino acid most responsible for triggering muscle protein synthesis (MPS).

A typical whey protein serving contains about 2.5-3g of leucine. Plant proteins typically deliver 1.5-2g per serving. The leucine threshold for maximally stimulating MPS is roughly 2.5g, which whey clears easily while many plant proteins fall just short.

However, this difference narrows significantly with blended plant proteins. A pea + rice combination (which is what most quality plant proteins use, including Orgain) provides a more complete amino acid profile than either source alone, because pea protein is high in lysine while rice protein is high in methionine — they complement each other.

Bottom line: Whey has a slight per-serving advantage. Blended plant proteins close the gap considerably. If you eat 1-2 extra grams of plant protein per serving, the amino acid difference becomes negligible.

Muscle Building and Recovery

#

This is the question most people care about: does whey build more muscle?

The short answer: barely, if at all, when total protein intake is matched.

A 2019 meta-analysis published in Sports Medicine by Messina et al. compared soy/plant protein to animal protein across multiple resistance training studies. The conclusion: no significant difference in lean mass gains when protein intake was equated.

A more targeted study by Banaszek et al. (2019) found that pea protein produced equivalent gains in muscle thickness, force production, and workout performance compared to whey protein over 8 weeks of high-intensity training.

Whey does spike blood amino acid levels faster (reaching peak levels in about 60-90 minutes vs. 90-120 for plant protein), which theoretically could matter for post-workout recovery. In practice, this difference hasn’t translated to measurable advantages in trained individuals consuming adequate daily protein.

Bottom line: If you eat enough total protein and train consistently, whey and plant protein produce comparable results. Whey may have a marginal edge for people eating at the minimum protein threshold.

Digestion and Tolerance

#

This is where individual differences matter most.

Whey contains lactose (especially whey concentrate), which causes bloating, gas, and stomach discomfort in people with lactose intolerance — estimated to affect 30-50 million Americans. Whey isolate has most lactose removed, making it tolerable for many people with mild intolerance.

Plant protein avoids dairy entirely, making it a clear choice for people with lactose intolerance or dairy allergies. However, plant proteins can cause their own digestive issues — some people are sensitive to pea protein specifically, and the fiber content of plant proteins can cause gas in some individuals.

Bottom line: If dairy bothers you, plant protein is the obvious choice. If you tolerate dairy fine, whey is typically easier to digest and causes fewer issues due to lower fiber content. Many quality plant proteins (like Orgain) include digestive enzymes to improve tolerance.

Taste and Mixability

#

Whey wins this category for most people. Decades of flavor engineering have produced whey proteins that taste genuinely good — chocolate, vanilla, and specialty flavors that many people look forward to drinking.

Plant proteins have improved dramatically but still tend to have a slightly earthy, gritty, or chalky quality compared to whey. The best plant proteins (Orgain, GHOST Vegan) have narrowed the gap significantly, but whey still has the edge in a blind taste test for most people.

Mixability is also better with whey — it dissolves more completely in a shaker bottle with less clumping. Plant proteins work best in a blender, especially when mixed with fruit.

Nutritional Profile Comparison

#

Environmental Impact

#

Plant protein has a meaningful advantage here. Dairy production requires significantly more water, land, and energy than pea or rice cultivation, and generates substantially more greenhouse gas emissions per gram of protein.

If environmental sustainability is a factor in your purchasing decisions, plant protein is the clear winner. This gap isn’t close.

Cost

#

Whey is generally cheaper per gram of protein, largely due to economies of scale — it’s the bigger market. However, the difference is modest (about 1-3 cents per gram), and plant protein prices continue to come down.

Product Breakdown

#

Choose Whey If You…

#

• Tolerate dairy well
• Prioritize taste and mixability
• Want the highest leucine content per serving
• Are budget-conscious (slightly cheaper per gram)
• Want the widest variety of flavor options
• Are an athlete who needs to maximize recovery efficiency

Choose Plant Protein If You…

#

• Are lactose intolerant or dairy-sensitive
• Follow a vegan or plant-based diet
• Want an organic, soy-free option
• Care about environmental sustainability
• Prefer cleaner ingredients and shorter labels
• Experience bloating or GI issues with whey

Our Bottom Line

#

For most people, whey protein is the better choice — it’s cheaper per gram, tastes better, mixes more easily, and has a slight amino acid advantage. ON Gold Standard remains our top recommendation.

For those who avoid dairy or prefer plant-based nutrition, Orgain Organic is an excellent option that delivers comparable muscle-building results when protein intake is adequate.

The most important factor isn’t whey vs. plant — it’s hitting your daily protein target consistently. The best protein powder is the one you’ll actually use every day.

For our complete rankings, see our best protein powder for women guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

#

Is whey or plant protein better for building muscle?

Whey has a slight per-serving edge due to higher leucine content. However, research shows no significant difference in muscle gain when total protein intake is matched.

Is plant protein a complete protein?

Most quality plant protein powders use blends (like pea + rice) that provide a complete amino acid profile.

Does plant protein cause bloating?

It varies by individual. Many people who bloat from whey find plant protein easier. Some people are sensitive to specific plant sources.

Which is better for weight loss?

Both are equally effective for weight loss when used as part of a calorie-controlled, high-protein diet. Total protein intake matters far more than the source.